Blog

How to choose a learning management system: questions to ask every vendor

20 November 2026 ยท 5 min read

Can we show who completed which training and when, in a report we can export ourselves at any time?

A learning management system, or LMS, is where you put training, assign it to people and track who has finished it. This guide is for small and mid-sized businesses that train their own staff: onboarding, product training, safety courses or required yearly refreshers. Some also train customers or partners.

If your training lives in shared folders, slide decks and a spreadsheet of who did what, an LMS can bring it into one place. But an LMS is only useful if people can find their courses and you can prove who completed them.

What goes wrong when you buy on a demo

A demo shows a polished course with video, quizzes and a certificate at the end. It looks good because the vendor built it for the demo. The real question is how long it will take you to build your own courses, with your own files and your own staff.

Demos also skip the admin work. Who adds new starters? Who removes people who leave? How do you assign a course to one team, then chase the people who have not done it? And when someone asks for proof of training, how quickly can you produce it?

These are the jobs you will do every week. Ask every vendor the same questions in writing, so you can compare them on that work, not on a sample course.

Must ask

  1. "How do we build a course from our existing files, such as slides, documents and videos?" Ask what formats it accepts, and how long a simple course takes to set up. Ask whether it supports standard course packages if you buy content elsewhere.
  2. "How are people added and removed, and can that happen automatically from our staff records?" Manual user lists fall out of date fast. Ask about a connection to your HR system or your sign-in system.
  3. "Can we assign courses by role, team or start date, and send reminders automatically?" Chasing people by hand is most of the admin time in training.
  4. "What completion records do you keep, and can we export a report showing who finished what and when?" If you need training records for audits, ask how long they are kept and whether you can get them after you leave.
  5. "Can staff take courses on a phone, and on a shared device?" Frontline staff may not have a laptop or a work email.
  6. "Can we set courses to repeat, such as a yearly refresher, and track when each person is due?" Required training often expires. You need to see who is overdue before it matters.
  7. "Can we export all our courses, users and records ourselves, in a standard format?" Courses take time to build. You do not want them locked in if you switch.

Worth asking

  1. "What kinds of quizzes and tests can we build, and can we set a pass mark?" Some training needs proof of understanding, not just a click on "done".
  2. "Can we include training that happens in person, and record attendance?" Not all training is online. Records should cover both.
  3. "Can managers see their own team's progress without seeing everyone else's?" Managers chase their own people. They should not need an admin to run a report.
  4. "Can we train people outside the company, such as customers or partners, and is that priced differently?" External learners often have separate pricing.
  5. "Does it come with ready-made courses, and do they cost extra?" A content library can save time, but it is often a separate subscription.
  6. "Can we use our own logo and colours, and our own web address?" This matters more if customers will see it.

Hidden costs to look for

How to compare the answers

Put the written answers next to each other, one row per question. Then work through them in order.

  1. Must-haves first. If you need audit-ready completion records and a tool cannot export them, it is out, whatever the price.
  2. Read partial answers carefully. "You can do this with a third-party tool" means another cost and another login. "We can build that for you" may mean a paid project.
  3. Count the weekly admin. For each tool, ask how a new starter gets their courses, and how you find people who are overdue. Fewer manual steps matter more than extra features.
  4. Price for your size. Give every vendor the same numbers: staff, seasonal staff, external learners and the storage you expect. Compare the first-year and second-year totals side by side.
  5. Build one real course. On a trial, build one short course from your own files, assign it to a test team and pull the completion report.

When you are ready to make a shortlist, see companies that sell learning management systems. NeutralPick lets you send them all the same questions for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.

Ask every LMS vendor the same questions in writing, and compare the answers side by side.

Build a checklist