A payment processor lets you take card and digital payments, in a shop, online, over the phone or by invoice. It moves the money from your customer to your bank account and takes a fee on the way. For most small businesses, that fee is one of the largest software costs they have, even though it never shows up as a subscription.
This guide is for small and mid-sized businesses: a café with one card reader, an online shop with a few hundred orders a month, or a service business that sends invoices and takes deposits. The questions are the same whether you take ten payments a day or ten thousand.
What goes wrong when you buy on a demo
A demo or sign-up page shows one rate. It is usually the rate for a common domestic card, taken in the most common way. Your real mix is different. Some customers pay with business cards, cards from abroad or premium reward cards, and these often cost more. Some payments are keyed in by hand, which may cost more again.
The demo also shows the money arriving. It does not show the day a large payment is held for review, the refund that still costs you the original fee, or the dispute that arrives months later with its own charge. These are the moments that decide whether a provider works for you.
Before you speak to anyone, write down your monthly card volume, your average sale, how you take payments and how many come from abroad. Then ask every provider the same questions, in writing.
Must ask
- What is the total fee per sale for our mix of cards? Ask for the rate for each type: domestic, international, business, premium and keyed-in. A single headline rate tells you little.
- Is the pricing flat-rate or based on the card network's cost plus a margin? Ask them to explain which applies to you and how it changes as your volume grows.
- Are there monthly, minimum or account fees? Some providers charge a monthly fee, or a minimum charge if your fees fall below a set amount.
- How fast do we get paid, and does faster payout cost extra? Ask how many days a payment takes to reach your bank and whether same-day or next-day payout has a fee.
- When can you hold or delay our money? Ask what triggers a reserve or a hold, how long it lasts and how you will be told. A surprise hold can stop a small business paying its own bills.
- What does a dispute or chargeback cost, and who handles it? Ask for the fee per dispute, whether it is refunded if you win, and what help you get.
- Do refunds cost us anything? Ask whether the original fee is returned when you refund a sale.
Worth asking
- What hardware do we need, and do we buy or rent it? Ask for the price of each reader and whether rental runs on a long contract.
- Does it work with our till, booking or accounting software? Ask whether the link is built in or needs another tool, and what it costs.
- How long is the contract, and what does it cost to leave? Ask about early exit fees and notice periods.
- Who is responsible for card security compliance, and is there a fee? Some providers charge a yearly compliance fee, or a penalty if a form is not filed.
- Which payment methods are included? Ask about digital wallets, bank transfers and pay-later options, and whether each has a different fee.
- What support do we get when a payment fails? Ask about hours, channels and response times, especially at weekends if you trade then.
- Can we export our transaction history if we move? Ask for the format, and whether stored customer card details can be moved to a new provider.
The hidden costs to look for
- Card mix. International, business and premium cards often cost more than the headline rate.
- Keyed-in and phone payments. Payments typed in by hand may carry a higher rate.
- Payout fees. Faster access to your own money may cost a percentage of each payout.
- Currency conversion. A margin on the exchange rate is easy to miss on statements.
- Dispute fees. A charge per chargeback, sometimes kept even when you win.
- Compliance and statement fees. Small yearly or monthly charges that add up.
- Hardware rental. A low monthly rental on a long contract can cost more than buying.
Tax on fees and how you record them depends on where you trade. Check with your accountant.
How to compare the written answers
Put every answer in one table: one row per question, one column per provider. Then work through it in this order.
- Check the must-haves first. If a provider cannot take payments the way your customers pay, or cannot pay you out fast enough to run the business, it is out.
- Treat partial answers as partial. "It depends" is not a rate. Ask again for a figure based on your volume and mix, and mark it as unanswered until you get one.
- Price it for your size. Take last month's real sales. Apply each provider's rates to your actual mix of cards and methods. Add monthly fees, hardware, payout fees and a fair estimate of refunds and disputes. Compare the yearly totals.
- Weigh the risks, not only the price. A slightly cheaper provider with unclear hold rules may cost more in a bad month.
Once you have a shortlist, ask each provider for a written quote based on the figures you gave. Keep it with the contract.
You can also see companies that sell payment processing. NeutralPick lets you send them all the same checklist for free, and no provider pays to be shown or ranked.