Many small businesses hire from a shared inbox and a spreadsheet. It works until several roles are open at once, candidates fall through the gaps, and nobody can find the notes from last week's interviews. An applicant tracking system, or ATS, keeps every candidate, every role and every piece of feedback in one place.
This article is for a small or mid-sized business, of about 10 to 300 people, that hires a few times a year or a few times a month and has no large recruiting team. Ask every vendor the questions below in writing, then compare the answers side by side.
What goes wrong when you buy on a demo
An ATS demo shows a tidy board of candidates moving from stage to stage. It is run by someone who uses the tool all day. Your hiring managers will open it once a week, in a hurry. After signing, the common problems are:
- hiring managers find it confusing and send feedback by email instead,
- each manager who looks at candidates needs a paid seat,
- posting to job boards costs extra, or only some boards are included,
- the application form is long, so good candidates give up halfway,
- old candidate data is kept forever, with no easy way to delete it.
Ask about each of these in writing before you sign.
Must ask
- Who counts as a paid user, and do hiring managers and interviewers need a paid seat? Pricing can be per recruiter, per user or per open job. The answer changes the cost a lot for a small team.
- Can a hiring manager review candidates and leave feedback from a phone, without training? If managers will not use it, the ATS becomes a second inbox.
- Which job boards can we post to from the system, and which are free? Ask about the boards you already use and any that matter in your country or industry.
- How long does it take a candidate to apply, and does the form work well on a phone? Many people apply from a phone. Ask to try the form yourself.
- Can we set how long candidate data is kept, and delete it when a candidate asks? Data protection laws in many countries cover job applicants. Check with an adviser which rules apply to you.
- Can we set our own hiring stages and scorecards for each role? A warehouse role and an office role may need different steps.
- Can we export all candidates, notes and files ourselves, in a standard format? You may need the history later, or want to move to another tool.
Worth asking
- Does it connect to our calendar so candidates can book interview times themselves? Arranging interviews by email takes a lot of time.
- Can we email candidates from the system, using our own templates? Every candidate should hear back, including the ones you turn down.
- Does it connect to our HR or payroll software when someone is hired? Otherwise someone types the new starter's details again.
- Can we keep a pool of past candidates and search it for new roles? Your second choice for one job may be right for the next.
- Does it rank or screen candidates automatically, and how does that work? Ask what the system decides, what you can see, and whether you can switch it off. Rules on automated hiring decisions differ by place, so check with an adviser.
- Can we build a careers page with our own branding? Useful if you hire often and want candidates to see all your open roles in one place.
Hidden costs in an applicant tracking system
- Seats for managers. If every interviewer needs a paid seat, a cheap plan for one recruiter can become expensive.
- Per-job pricing. Some plans limit the number of open jobs. A busy hiring season can push you up a plan.
- Job board fees. Free posting may only cover some boards. Paid or promoted listings are charged separately, and some go through the vendor.
- Add-ons. Interview scheduling, background checks, assessments and e-signatures for offer letters are often extra.
- Setup and data import. Moving past candidates from spreadsheets or an old tool may carry a fee.
- Annual contracts for uneven hiring. If you hire in bursts, an annual plan may mean paying through months with no open roles. Ask whether you can pause or move to a smaller plan.
How to compare the written answers
Put the answers side by side, one row per question and one column per vendor.
- Start with the must-haves. If hiring managers cannot use it easily, or you cannot delete candidate data when you need to, the rest matters less.
- Read partial answers closely. "Integrates with job boards" may mean a few boards, or only paid listings. "Mobile friendly" may mean the candidate form, not the manager view. Note the plan each answer applies to.
- Price for your size. Use your real number of recruiters, hiring managers and interviewers, and the number of roles you expect to have open at once. Add job board costs and add-ons.
- Compare two years. Include setup in the first year, and the renewal price the vendor confirms in writing for the second.
If a vendor will not answer a question in writing, write that down as the answer.
When you are ready to ask, you can see companies that sell applicant tracking systems. NeutralPick lets you send them all the same questions for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.