Blog

How to choose backup software for a small business: questions to ask every vendor

20 November 2026 ยท 4 min read

If we lost everything today, how long would it take to restore all our data, and can we test that ourselves?

Most small businesses only find out whether their backup works on the day they need it. A laptop is stolen, a server fails, a file is deleted by mistake, or ransomware locks every shared folder. At that point, the only question that matters is how fast you get your data back.

This article is for a small or mid-sized business, of about 5 to 200 people, that is choosing backup software for the first time or replacing a setup it no longer trusts. That might cover staff laptops, a file server, cloud email and documents, or business software you run yourself.

What goes wrong when you buy on a demo

A backup demo shows a green dashboard and a single file restored in seconds. Real recovery is different:

A demo cannot show any of this. Written answers, and a test restore, can.

Must ask

  1. What exactly can you back up? List your laptops, servers, cloud email, shared documents and databases, and ask which are covered on the plan you would buy.
  2. How long would it take to restore all our data, and how do you get it to us? Ask for a realistic time for your amount of data over your internet connection. This decides how long your business stops.
  3. Can someone with our admin password change or delete the backups? Ask whether backups can be locked so no one, including an attacker, can delete them for a set period. This is your protection against ransomware.
  4. How often do backups run, and how far back can we restore? If backups run once a night, you can lose a day of work. Ask how many past versions you keep, and for how long.
  5. How do you tell us when a backup fails? You need an alert to a person, not a log nobody reads.
  6. Can we run a test restore ourselves, at any time, at no charge? A backup you have never restored is a guess.
  7. Where are backups stored, who can read them, and are they encrypted? Ask who holds the encryption key. Check with an adviser which data rules apply to you.

Worth asking

  1. Do you keep a copy in a second location? One copy in the same building as the original gives little protection from fire or flood.
  2. Can we restore one file, one mailbox or one folder without restoring everything? Most restores are small. They should be quick and simple.
  3. Can a whole computer or server be restored to new hardware? Useful when the original machine is gone.
  4. Does backup slow down our computers or internet during the working day? Ask whether you can schedule it or limit the bandwidth it uses.
  5. What support do we get during a real recovery, and how fast do you respond? A recovery often happens at night or at a weekend.
  6. If we stop paying, how long do you keep our backups, and can we download them first? You should not lose your only copy when a contract ends.

Hidden costs in backup software

How to compare the written answers

Put the answers side by side, one row per question and one column per vendor.

  1. Start with the must-haves. Full coverage of your data, a restore time you can live with and backups that cannot be deleted come before anything else.
  2. Treat vague answers as gaps. "Restores are fast" is not a time. "We support ransomware protection" does not say how. Ask for the detail, and note the plan each answer applies to.
  3. Price for your size. Use your real number of devices and mailboxes, your current amount of data, and the growth you expect over two years. Add restore fees and add-ons.
  4. Test before you commit. If you can, run a trial and restore something real. Write down how long it took.

If a vendor will not answer a question in writing, note that as the answer.

When you are ready to ask, you can see companies that sell backup and recovery software. NeutralPick lets you send them all the same questions for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.

Ask every backup vendor the same questions in writing, and compare their answers side by side.

Build a checklist