Blog

How to choose expense management software: questions to ask every vendor

20 November 2026 ยท 5 min read

What will we pay each month for our number of staff who submit expenses, including cards and approvals?

Expense management software replaces the spreadsheet, the shoebox of receipts and the email chain asking a manager to approve a taxi fare. Staff photograph a receipt, the tool reads it, a manager approves it, and the claim flows into your accounts. Some tools also issue company cards, so spending shows up before anyone files a claim.

This guide is for small and mid-sized businesses, from a team of ten with a few travelling staff to a company of a few hundred with several approvers and more than one office. If one person does the books and everyone else spends, it is for you too.

What goes wrong when you buy on a demo

A demo shows one perfect receipt. It is printed clearly, in one currency, for one amount, approved by one manager. Real receipts are crumpled, faded, handwritten or in another language. Real claims have a hotel bill split across two cost centres, a mileage claim and a lost receipt.

The demo also hides who pays. Many tools charge per active user, and the person who submits one claim a year may count the same as someone who travels every week. Card features, accounting sync and multi-level approvals are often on a higher plan than the one shown. You find out after the contract is signed, when the first month-end close goes badly.

The fix is simple. Write down how your business actually spends, then ask every vendor the same questions in writing.

Must ask

  1. Who counts as a paid user? Ask whether you pay for everyone with a login, only people who submit a claim that month, or approvers too. This decides most of the price.
  2. Does it connect to our accounting software, and how? Ask whether the sync is built in or needs a third-party tool, and whether it posts to the right accounts, cost centres and tax codes. A weak sync means someone re-keys every claim.
  3. How well does it read receipts, and what happens when it gets one wrong? Ask whether receipts are read by software only or checked by people, how long it takes, and how staff correct a mistake.
  4. Can we set the approval rules we need? Describe your rules, such as a manager for small claims and a director above a set amount. Ask whether the tool handles them on the plan you are quoted.
  5. Can we set spending policies that flag problems before approval? Ask about limits per category, per day or per trip, and whether the tool warns the person who submits, the approver, or both.
  6. How are staff paid back? Ask whether reimbursement runs through the tool, through payroll, or by a file you upload to your bank, and whether there is a fee per payment.
  7. What does it cost for our team, all in, for the first and second year? Give the same number of submitters and approvers to every vendor, and ask for the plan that includes all your must-haves.

Worth asking

  1. Do you offer company cards, and what do they cost? Ask about card fees, foreign transaction fees, and whether you must use their cards to get the full product.
  2. How does it handle other currencies? Ask which exchange rate it uses and whether staff can claim in the currency they paid in.
  3. How does it handle mileage and per diems? Ask whether rates are set by you or built in, and how distance is recorded.
  4. Does it keep receipts in a way our accountant will accept? Ask how long images are stored and whether they can be exported with the claim. Check the rules for your country with your accountant.
  5. Does the mobile app work offline? Staff often snap receipts on a train or in a basement car park.
  6. Can we export all our claims and receipts if we leave? Ask for the format and whether it costs anything.

The hidden costs to look for

How to compare the written answers

Put the answers in one table, with one row per question and one column per vendor. Then work through it in this order.

  1. Check the must-haves first. If a vendor cannot sync with your accounting software or handle your approval rules, it is out, however good the rest looks.
  2. Treat partial answers as partial. "Yes, with a workaround" or "on our next plan" is not a yes. Mark it clearly and ask what the workaround costs in time or money.
  3. Price it for your size. Use your real number of submitters, approvers and cards. Add setup, reimbursement fees and card fees. Compare the first-year and second-year totals, not the monthly headline.
  4. Note what was not answered. A vendor that will not say who counts as a paid user has given you an answer.

Once you have a shortlist, run a short trial with real receipts from last month. Ask your bookkeeper to close one period with it before you sign.

You can also see companies that sell expense management software. NeutralPick lets you send them all the same checklist for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.

Ask every expense management vendor the same questions in writing, and compare the answers side by side.

Build a checklist