This article is for a small or mid-sized business that holds stock. You might run a shop, sell online, supply trade customers, or do all three. You may track stock in spreadsheets today, or in a tool you have outgrown. Either way, the next system has to tell you what you have, where it is, and when to order more.
In this article, a vendor is a company that sells inventory management software.
Why a demo is not enough
A demo shows a tidy warehouse with a few products, one location and no mistakes. Your stock is not like that. You have product variants, items that arrive in boxes and sell one at a time, returns, damaged goods and orders coming in from several places at once.
The problems usually show up after you sign. For example:
- an item sells online after the last one has gone in the shop,
- stock counts drift away from what is on the shelf, and no one can see why,
- the import of your product list loses variants or barcodes,
- the connection to your accounting software only sends totals, not the detail your accountant needs.
So ask about these in writing, and ask every vendor the same questions. Then you can compare the answers line by line.
Must ask
- Do stock levels update everywhere at once when we sell in more than one place? Selling the same item twice is a common and costly mistake. Ask how quickly a sale in one channel changes the count in the others.
- Can we see the history of every stock change for one item? When a count is wrong, you need to see each sale, receipt, transfer and adjustment, with who made it and when.
- Does it handle our product variants and units? Ask about sizes, colours, packs and items bought by the case but sold singly. Some systems treat each variant as a separate product, which makes reports hard to read.
- Can we run stock counts without stopping sales? Ask whether you can count one area or one group of products at a time, using a phone or barcode scanner.
- How does it track stock in more than one location? This includes a back room, a second shop, a warehouse or a van. Ask how transfers between them are recorded.
- Can we import our current products, stock levels and suppliers, and will you help? A bad first import means wrong counts from the first day.
- What does it send to our accounting software, and how often? Ask whether it sends stock value, cost of goods sold and purchase invoices, or only sales totals.
- Can we export all our data ourselves, in a standard format, at any time? This is what lets you leave later without retyping your product list.
Worth asking
- Can it suggest when to reorder, based on rules we set? Reorder points that you set per item take a lot of guesswork out of buying.
- Can we create purchase orders and receive stock against them? This shows what you ordered, what arrived and what is still missing.
- Does it track batch numbers, serial numbers or expiry dates? This matters if you sell food, health products, electronics or anything that may be recalled.
- Which barcode scanners and label printers does it work with? Hardware you already own may not be supported.
- Can we limit what each user can see and change? Not everyone should be able to adjust stock or see cost prices.
The hidden costs
The monthly price is only part of what you will pay. Ask about each of these in writing:
- Limits on orders, products or locations. Many plans cap the number of orders per month, products or locations. Growth can push you onto a higher plan.
- Sales channel connections. Each connection to an online store or marketplace may be a paid add-on.
- Hardware. Scanners, label printers and mobile devices may need to be bought or replaced.
- Accounting connection. The connection may only be on a higher plan, or need a third-party tool with its own fee.
- Setup and data import. Some vendors charge to import products or set up locations.
- Extra users. Warehouse staff who only scan items may still count as paid users.
How to compare the answers
Put every vendor's written answers side by side, question by question. Then work through them in this order.
- Must-haves first. Drop any vendor that cannot do a must-have on the plan you would buy. A feature on a higher plan is a different price, not a yes.
- Treat partial answers as partial. "Yes, with a workaround" or "coming soon" is not the same as yes. Ask for detail, or mark it as no.
- Price it for your size. Use your real number of products, orders per month, locations and users, plus the growth you expect. Add the hidden costs above, and compare first-year and second-year totals.
Before you decide, ask each vendor on your shortlist to run a trial with a slice of your real product list, including your awkward items. If a vendor will not answer a question in writing, note that as an answer too. If you are still building your shortlist, you can see companies that sell inventory management software. NeutralPick lets you send every vendor the same questions for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.