Project management software keeps a team's work in one place: projects, tasks, who is doing what, deadlines, files and the conversation around each piece of work. For a small team it usually replaces a whiteboard, a shared spreadsheet and a long trail of messages asking whether something is done.
This guide is for teams choosing their first project management tool, or leaving one that the team stopped using. Most tools look alike in a demo. The differences show up in who has to pay for a seat, what guests and clients can do, and whether the tool fits the way your team actually plans work.
Why a project management demo can mislead you
A project management demo shows a neat board with a few colourful tasks moving from left to right. It is usually the top plan, with timelines, workload views, automations and reports switched on. Your team will work on a cheaper plan, with dozens of overlapping projects and people who forget to update their tasks.
The surprises come later. The timeline view you liked is two plans up. Every freelancer and client you invite takes a paid seat. Time tracking needs a separate tool. The tool is so flexible that every project ends up set up differently, and nobody can find anything.
So write down how your team actually plans and tracks work, and ask every vendor the same questions in writing.
Must ask
- Which plan includes all of our must-haves? Give them your list: boards, lists, timelines, dependencies, recurring tasks, reports. Ask for the cheapest plan that covers all of it, by name, and any limit on projects, tasks or storage in that plan.
- Who needs a paid seat? Team members, managers who only check progress, freelancers, and people from other departments who comment now and then. Ask whether there are cheaper or free limited seats.
- What can guests and clients do, and do they cost anything? Ask whether you can invite someone outside the company to one project only, whether they can see other projects by mistake, and how many guests are free.
- How do permissions work? Ask whether you can control who can see, edit or delete each project, and whether private projects or tasks are possible on your plan.
- Which views are included? List, board, calendar, timeline or Gantt, workload. Ask which ones are on your plan, and whether each person can choose their own view of the same work.
- What connects to it without extra cost? Your email, calendar, chat tool, file storage and the software where requests arrive. Ask which connections are built in and which need a paid connector or a higher plan.
- Can we get all our data out, at any time, in a standard format? Ask whether the export includes comments, attachments, subtasks and history, not just a list of task names.
Worth asking
- Is time tracking built in? Ask whether people can log time against tasks, whether time can be marked billable, and whether you can report on it or need another tool.
- How do we move our existing projects? From spreadsheets or another tool. Ask whether tasks, dates, owners and comments come across, and whether help is free.
- Which automations are included, and how many? Assigning tasks, moving them when a status changes and sending reminders are often limited by plan or by a monthly count.
- Can we set up templates? Ask whether a standard project can be copied with its tasks, dates and owners, so every project starts the same way.
- What does the mobile app do? Ask whether people can update tasks, add comments and attach photos from a phone.
- What support do we get on our plan? Email, chat or phone, which hours, and whether onboarding help is included.
The hidden costs
Project management software is usually priced per user, per month, and often sold in minimum seat bundles. Ask about each of these in writing:
- Plan upgrades needed for timelines, workload, reports or permissions.
- Minimum seat counts, where you pay for a bundle of seats larger than your team.
- Guest limits, and the price once guests start counting as paid seats.
- Automation or integration limits, and the price above them.
- Storage limits for files attached to tasks.
- Time tracking or reporting sold as an add-on or a separate tool.
- Annual commitment behind the advertised monthly price.
- Price increases at renewal. Ask for a cap in writing.
How to compare the answers
Put every vendor's written answers side by side, question by question. Then work through them in this order:
- Must-haves first. If a view or permission you need is only in a higher plan, compare that plan's price, not the cheaper one.
- Then the seats. Count everyone who will touch the tool, including guests, and work out who pays for a seat with each vendor.
- Then the two-year total for that number of seats, with the add-ons you actually need.
- Then a real trial. Run one live project in the tool for two weeks with the whole team and at least one guest before you sign.
Only then book detailed demos, and ask each vendor to show one of your real projects, on the plan you would buy. If you want to see who sells this kind of software, see companies that sell project management software. NeutralPick lets you send every vendor the same questions and compare their written answers side by side, for free, with no paid ranking.