This article is for a small or mid-sized landlord or letting business. You might manage a handful of flats, a few hundred homes, or a mix of homes and small commercial units. You may track rent, repairs and tenancies in spreadsheets, email and a separate accounting tool today. The next system has to keep rent, tenants, repairs and money in one place you can trust.
In this article, a vendor is a company that sells property management software.
Why a demo is not enough
A demo shows tenants who pay on time, one bank account and a repair that is fixed in a day. Your portfolio is not like that. Rent arrives late or in part, some owners want their own statements, deposits have rules, and repairs pass between tenants, contractors and owners.
The problems usually show up after you sign. For example:
- part payments and late fees do not match what the bank shows,
- owner statements need fixing by hand every month,
- repair requests still arrive by text and phone, so the system is out of date,
- the import of old tenancies loses balances or documents.
So ask about these in writing, and ask every vendor the same questions. Then you can compare the answers line by line.
Must ask
- How does it match rent payments to tenants when the amount is wrong or late? Ask how it handles part payments, overpayments, one payment for two months and payments with no reference.
- Can it match transactions from our bank account automatically? Ask which banks it connects to, and what you do by hand when a payment does not match.
- Can we produce statements for each owner, in the format they need? If you manage for other owners, ask how fees, repairs and payments to owners appear on each statement.
- How do tenants report repairs, and how do we track them to the end? Ask whether tenants can send photos, whether contractors can update the job, and whether the owner can approve costs.
- Does it keep deposits separate and track them correctly? Deposit rules differ by place. Ask how the system records them, and check the rules that apply to you with an adviser.
- Does it remind us about tenancy renewals, rent reviews and safety checks? Missed dates can cost money and cause trouble with tenants.
- Can we import our properties, tenants, balances and documents, and will you help? Opening balances that are wrong on day one stay wrong for months.
- Can we export all our data ourselves, in a standard format, at any time? Ask whether this includes payment history and documents, not just contact details.
Worth asking
- Is there a portal or app for tenants and owners? Ask what each can see and do, such as pay rent, report a repair or download a statement.
- Can tenants sign tenancy documents online? This saves printing and chasing signatures.
- Does it handle advertising empty units and screening applicants? Some systems do this, others leave it to separate tools.
- What does it send to our accounting software? Ask whether it sends full transaction detail or only totals, and whether it works per owner.
- Can we limit what each user can see and change? Not every staff member should see owner balances or tenant bank details.
The hidden costs
The monthly price is only part of what you will pay. Ask about each of these in writing:
- Pricing per unit. Many vendors charge per property or per unit, often with a minimum. Check whether empty units, garages or parking spaces count.
- Payment fees. Online rent payments may carry a fee per payment. Ask who pays it, you or the tenant.
- Applicant screening. Background or credit checks are often charged per applicant.
- Bank connections. Automatic bank matching may be an add-on or limited to some banks.
- Features on a higher plan. Owner statements, tenant portals and repair tracking are often on a more expensive plan.
- Setup and data import. Moving tenancies, balances and documents may be a paid service.
How to compare the answers
Put every vendor's written answers side by side, question by question. Then work through them in this order.
- Must-haves first. Drop any vendor that cannot do a must-have on the plan you would buy. Rent matching and owner statements are usually the first to check.
- Treat partial answers as partial. "You can export it and adjust it" or "planned for next year" is not a full yes. Ask for detail, or mark it as no.
- Price it for your size. Use your real number of units, owners, staff users and online payments, plus the units you expect to add. Add the hidden costs above, and compare first-year and second-year totals.
Before you decide, ask each vendor to show your own messiest month of rent payments in a trial, not their sample data. If a vendor will not answer a question in writing, note that as an answer too. If you are still building your shortlist, you can see companies that sell property management software. NeutralPick lets you send every vendor the same questions for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.