This article is for a small or mid-sized restaurant, café, bar or takeaway, or a group of a few sites. You may use an old till, a paper order pad, a separate delivery tablet for each delivery service, and a spreadsheet for stock and staff hours. The next system has to take orders, get them to the kitchen and take payment, quickly, on your busiest night.
In this article, a vendor is a company that sells restaurant management software. That usually means a point of sale system, often with kitchen screens, online ordering, stock, staff and reports.
Why a demo is not enough
A demo shows one order at a time, a fast internet connection and a menu with ten items. Your Friday night is not like that. Orders come from tables, the counter, your website and delivery services at once. Guests split bills, change dishes and ask for items without an ingredient.
The problems usually show up after you sign. For example:
- the internet drops during service and the tills stop taking card payments,
- delivery orders still arrive on separate tablets and are typed in again,
- menu changes have to be made in several places,
- you find you are tied to the vendor's card payment service at a rate you did not compare.
So ask about these in writing, and ask every vendor the same questions. Then you can compare the answers line by line.
Must ask
- What still works when our internet connection goes down? Ask whether you can take orders, send them to the kitchen and take card payments offline, and what happens to those payments later.
- Must we use your card payment service, and what does it charge? Ask for the fee on each type of card payment in writing, and whether you can use your own provider.
- Do delivery and online orders go straight to the till and the kitchen? Ask which delivery services connect, whether each connection costs extra, and whether menu changes update everywhere.
- How do orders reach the kitchen? Ask whether it supports kitchen screens, printers or both, and whether orders can go to different stations such as the grill and the bar.
- How does it handle split bills, changes and allergy notes? Ask to see it split a bill by item and by guest, and how allergy notes show in the kitchen.
- Which hardware must we buy, and can we use what we already have? Ask whether tills, card readers and printers are bought, rented or tied to the contract.
- What does it send to our accounting software? Ask whether it sends sales by category, tax, tips and payment type, or only daily totals.
- Can we export all our sales, menu and customer data ourselves, at any time? This keeps your history if you change systems.
Worth asking
- Can it track stock and ingredients against what we sell? This shows waste and tells you when to order, if the recipes are set up well.
- Does it handle staff rotas, clock-in and tips? Ask how tips are recorded and shared, and what it sends to payroll.
- Can we manage more than one site from one account? Ask whether menus, prices and reports can be shared or kept separate per site.
- Does it take table bookings, or connect to our booking tool? Bookings that sit outside the till make it harder to plan the floor.
- Can we limit what each staff member can do on the till? Refunds, discounts and voids should need a manager.
The hidden costs
The monthly price is only part of what you will pay. Ask about each of these in writing:
- Card payment fees. A low software price can come with a higher fee on every payment. Over a year this can be the largest cost, so compare it carefully.
- Hardware. Tills, card readers, kitchen screens and printers may be bought, rented or included only while the contract lasts.
- Per-terminal or per-site pricing. Each extra till, kitchen screen or site may add a monthly charge.
- Online ordering and delivery connections. These are often add-ons, and some charge a fee per order.
- Contract length and early exit. Hardware or payment deals may tie you in for several years, with a fee to leave early.
- Setup and menu building. Ask whether the vendor builds your menu and trains staff, and what that costs.
How to compare the answers
Put every vendor's written answers side by side, question by question. Then work through them in this order.
- Must-haves first. Drop any vendor that cannot do a must-have on the plan you would buy. Offline working and payment terms are usually the first to check.
- Treat partial answers as partial. "Cash only when offline" or "available through a partner" is not a full yes. Ask for detail, or mark it as no.
- Price it for your size. Use your real number of tills, sites, staff and card sales per month. Add payment fees, hardware and the hidden costs above, and compare first-year and second-year totals.
If a vendor will not answer a question in writing, note that as an answer too. If you are still building your shortlist, you can see companies that sell restaurant management software. NeutralPick lets you send every vendor the same questions for free, and no vendor pays to be shown or ranked.